DOJ Inspector General Flags Outdated AI Strategy as Major Challenge

DOJ Inspector General Flags Outdated AI Strategy as Major Challenge

The Justice Department's own watchdog is sounding the alarm about the agency's approach to artificial intelligence. In a new management report, the Office of the Inspector General highlighted the DOJ's failure to update its public AI strategy since 2020—well before the current AI boom transformed the technology landscape.

The OIG identified maintaining cybersecurity and keeping pace with emerging technologies like AI as top challenges facing the department. The criticism comes at a critical time when federal agencies are grappling with how to safely implement powerful new AI tools.

What's Missing from DOJ's AI Approach

The department's 2020 AI strategy predates the widespread availability of ChatGPT and other generative AI tools that have revolutionized the field. It also came before President Biden's October 2023 executive order requiring federal agencies to develop comprehensive AI governance frameworks.

Key gaps identified include:

• Outdated guidance: The 2020 strategy doesn't address current AI capabilities or risks
• Limited public transparency: No updated public-facing strategy despite rapid technological changes
• Reactive approach: The OIG warned the department "cannot afford to be reactive to the risks and consequences of AI"

Current AI Uses and Future Risks

The DOJ is already using AI for specific tasks like classifying drug samples and consolidating record reviews through topic modeling. However, the OIG emphasized significant risks ahead, noting there's "currently a lack of robust and verifiable measurement methods for risk and trustworthiness" in AI systems.

The inspector general warned that AI will "significantly affect the DOJ's efforts to uphold the rule of law, keep our country safe, and protect civil rights over time." To address these concerns, the OIG is currently auditing how the DEA and FBI integrate AI technologies.

What Happens Next

A DOJ spokesperson noted that a new AI strategy is required under Biden's executive order by March 2025, and pointed to the department's AI governance program as evidence of progress. However, uncertainty looms over whether the incoming Trump administration will maintain these requirements, given plans to potentially rescind Biden's AI order.

The Government Accountability Office reached similar conclusions in a May 2023 report, suggesting this challenge extends across the federal government.

Read the full article on FedScoop